Understanding Penalty Tries in Rugby


Rugby is a game of skill, strategy, and fairness, and the penalty try is one of the rules that upholds the integrity of the sport. For new fans or players, understanding what a penalty try is and how it works is crucial to fully appreciating the game. This blog will provide a comprehensive explanation of penalty tries, when they are awarded, their impact on the game, and notable examples from rugby history.


What is a Penalty Try?

A penalty try is a special type of scoring in rugby where the referee awards a team seven points without requiring the ball to be touched down in the in-goal area. Unlike a standard try, a penalty try does not require a conversion attempt as the points are automatically added.

The primary purpose of a penalty try is to penalize foul play by the defending team that prevents a probable try from being scored. It ensures that teams play fairly and do not gain an advantage through illegal actions.


When is a Penalty Try Awarded?

A penalty try is awarded when the referee determines that:

  1. A Try Would Have Been Scored
    • The attacking team was in a position to score a try but was prevented by an infringement from the defending team.
  2. Foul Play Occurred
    • The defending team committed an act of foul play, such as collapsing a maul, tackling a player without the ball, or deliberately knocking the ball forward.
  3. No Other Defenders Could Prevent the Try
    • The referee must be convinced that the attacking team would have scored if not for the infringement.

Common Scenarios Leading to Penalty Tries

  1. Deliberate Knock-On
    • A defender intentionally slaps the ball forward to disrupt a scoring opportunity, preventing a clean try-scoring chance.
  2. Collapsing a Maul or Scrum
    • When the attacking team drives toward the try line, and the defending team illegally collapses the maul or scrum to stop the momentum.
  3. High Tackles or Dangerous Play
    • A player is tackled high or dangerously in a clear try-scoring position.
  4. Pulling Down a Player in the Air
    • Defenders who interfere with players attempting to catch a high ball in the in-goal area may cause the awarding of a penalty try.
  5. Preventing a Quick Tap or Lineout
    • Delaying tactics or interference in quick restarts can lead to penalty tries if they prevent a probable score.

How Penalty Tries Are Awarded

The referee is the sole authority in determining whether to award a penalty try. They rely on the following tools and criteria:

  1. Positioning and Observation
    • Referees must have a clear view of the incident and assess the likelihood of a try being scored.
  2. TMO (Television Match Official)
    • In professional matches, referees can consult the TMO to review footage of the play and make an informed decision.
  3. Judgment of Intent
    • Referees assess whether the defending team’s actions were intentional or accidental.

Once awarded, the attacking team receives seven points automatically, and the match restarts with a kickoff from the center of the field.


Impact of Penalty Tries on the Game

  1. Discouraging Foul Play
    • Penalty tries serve as a deterrent for defending teams, emphasizing the importance of fair play.
  2. Strategic Advantage
    • Awarding a penalty try can shift momentum in favor of the attacking team, especially in close matches.
  3. Potential for Yellow or Red Cards
    • If the foul play involves dangerous or deliberate actions, the offending player may also receive a yellow or red card, reducing the team to fewer players.
  4. Psychological Effect
    • Penalty tries can demoralize defending teams while boosting the confidence of the attacking side.

Notable Penalty Tries in Rugby History

  1. 2019 Rugby World Cup Final
    • England’s attempts to prevent South Africa from driving over the line in a scrum resulted in a penalty try, which played a pivotal role in South Africa’s victory.
  2. Six Nations Championship
    • Penalty tries are often awarded in high-stakes Six Nations matches, showcasing their importance in tightly contested games.
  3. Super Rugby Thrillers
    • Teams in Super Rugby frequently encounter penalty tries due to the fast-paced and physical nature of the competition.

Differences Between Penalty Tries in Rugby Union and Rugby League

While both codes of rugby include penalty tries, there are some differences:

  1. Points Awarded
    • In rugby union, a penalty try is worth 7 points, while in rugby league, it is worth 6 points.
  2. Conversion Kicks
    • Rugby union does not require a conversion for penalty tries, but rugby league includes a conversion attempt.
  3. TMO Usage
    • Rugby union heavily relies on TMO reviews for penalty tries, whereas rugby league often makes quicker decisions.

Common Misconceptions About Penalty Tries

  1. It’s Always a Penalty Try If a Try Isn’t Scored
    • Not true. A penalty try is awarded only if a try would probably have been scored without the infringement.
  2. Any Foul Play Near the Try Line Leads to a Penalty Try
    • The referee must determine that the foul play directly prevented a try.
  3. Penalty Tries Don’t Happen Often
    • While less common than standard tries, penalty tries are a regular part of professional rugby and reflect the game’s commitment to fairness.

How Teams Can Avoid Conceding Penalty Tries

  1. Discipline in Defense
    • Maintaining composure and avoiding reckless actions near the try line.
  2. Communication
    • Clear communication among defenders can prevent last-ditch fouls.
  3. Adhering to Rules
    • Understanding and respecting the laws of the game reduce the likelihood of infringements.

Conclusion

Penalty tries are a vital aspect of rugby, ensuring fair play and punishing teams that resort to illegal tactics to prevent scoring. For new fans, understanding penalty tries enhances your appreciation of the sport’s rules and the strategic nuances that make rugby so captivating.

Whether it’s the drama of a collapsed maul or the precision of a referee’s decision, penalty tries remind us that rugby is a game where integrity and sportsmanship reign supreme. So, the next time you watch a match, keep an eye out for these pivotal moments that can change the course of the game!

Recent Posts