The Biggest Upsets in Rugby History


Rugby is a sport filled with passion, skill, and unpredictability. While many matches follow the expected script, there are moments when the underdog rises and defies all odds, creating unforgettable upsets. These games often become iconic, capturing the essence of rugby’s drama and excitement. Here, we delve into some of the biggest upsets in rugby history.


Japan vs. South Africa, 2015 Rugby World Cup

Arguably the most famous upset in rugby history occurred during the 2015 Rugby World Cup when Japan defeated South Africa 34-32 in Brighton. Known as the “Miracle of Brighton,” this match redefined the possibilities in international rugby.

  • Context: South Africa, a two-time World Cup champion, was expected to dominate. Japan had only one World Cup win in their history before this game.
  • Key Moments: Japan’s fearless approach, relentless defense, and a last-minute try by Karne Hesketh secured their victory.
  • Impact: This win elevated Japan’s status in rugby, leading to increased investment in the sport and a stellar performance as hosts in the 2019 World Cup.

Western Samoa vs. Wales, 1991 Rugby World Cup

Another unforgettable upset came in 1991 when Western Samoa stunned Wales 16-13 at Cardiff Arms Park.

  • Context: Wales, a traditional rugby powerhouse, had a strong record in the World Cup. Western Samoa, on the other hand, was making their debut in the tournament.
  • Key Moments: The Samoans played with physicality and flair, catching the Welsh team off guard. Brian Lima, known as the “Pacific Island Terminator,” made his World Cup debut in this match.
  • Impact: This victory put Pacific Island rugby on the map and inspired generations of players from the region.

France vs. New Zealand, 1999 Rugby World Cup

France’s semi-final victory over New Zealand in the 1999 Rugby World Cup is one of the greatest comebacks and upsets in rugby history.

  • Context: The All Blacks were heavy favorites, led by Jonah Lomu and a dominant squad.
  • Key Moments: Trailing 24-10 early in the second half, France unleashed an attacking masterclass, scoring 33 unanswered points to win 43-31. Christophe Lamaison’s kicking and Philippe Bernat-Salles’ try were instrumental.
  • Impact: This match demonstrated the unpredictable nature of knockout rugby and cemented France’s reputation as giant-killers.

Tonga vs. France, 2011 Rugby World Cup

In the pool stages of the 2011 Rugby World Cup, Tonga shocked France with a 19-14 victory.

  • Context: France, eventual finalists in the tournament, underestimated a determined Tongan side.
  • Key Moments: Tonga’s discipline and aggressive defense, combined with Kurt Morath’s precise kicking, secured their win.
  • Impact: Although Tonga didn’t progress further, this win remains a highlight in their rugby history.

Fiji vs. Wales, 2007 Rugby World Cup

Fiji’s 38-34 victory over Wales in the 2007 Rugby World Cup was a thrilling contest that eliminated the Welsh team from the tournament.

  • Context: Wales, former World Cup semi-finalists, were expected to advance from the pool stage. Fiji had not reached the quarter-finals since 1987.
  • Key Moments: The game saw an incredible display of attacking rugby, with Fiji’s Akapusi Qera and Graham Dewes scoring decisive tries.
  • Impact: This victory showcased Fiji’s flair and resilience, inspiring pride in Pacific Island rugby.

Uruguay vs. Fiji, 2019 Rugby World Cup

In one of the biggest shocks of the 2019 Rugby World Cup, Uruguay defeated Fiji 30-27 in Kamaishi.

  • Context: Fiji, known for their dynamic and physical style, were favorites to win. Uruguay, ranked much lower, had only two prior World Cup victories.
  • Key Moments: Felipe Berchesi’s accurate kicking and Uruguay’s tenacious defense sealed the historic win.
  • Impact: Uruguay’s triumph highlighted the growing competitiveness of Tier 2 nations in rugby.

Ireland vs. New Zealand, 2016

Ireland’s first-ever victory over New Zealand in 2016 was a monumental upset in rugby history.

  • Context: The All Blacks had dominated Ireland in all 28 previous encounters.
  • Key Moments: Played in Chicago, Ireland’s 40-29 win was powered by Robbie Henshaw’s decisive try and a disciplined team performance.
  • Impact: This victory ended a 111-year drought and marked Ireland’s rise as a global rugby powerhouse.

South Africa vs. England, 1999 Rugby World Cup

South Africa’s shock 44-21 victory over England in the 1999 quarter-finals was largely thanks to the heroics of Jannie de Beer.

  • Context: England were favorites, boasting a strong squad and home advantage in Paris.
  • Key Moments: De Beer’s record-breaking five drop goals turned the tide, securing an emphatic Springbok win.
  • Impact: This performance reinforced South Africa’s knack for thriving under pressure in World Cups.

Namibia vs. Canada, 2019 Rugby World Cup Cancellation

While not an on-field upset, the cancellation of the Namibia-Canada match during the 2019 Rugby World Cup due to Typhoon Hagibis had significant repercussions.

  • Context: Both teams sought their first win of the tournament. The cancellation denied Namibia a chance to secure their maiden World Cup victory.
  • Impact: Though not a traditional upset, this event underscored the unpredictable challenges of hosting a global tournament.

Conclusion

Rugby’s history is rich with moments when underdogs have defied expectations and delivered stunning upsets. These matches not only captivate fans but also showcase the spirit and unpredictability that make rugby so special. Whether it’s Japan’s “Miracle of Brighton” or Uruguay’s triumph over Fiji, these games remind us that in rugby, anything is possible.

Recent Posts