Most Underrated Rugby Players of All Time

In the illustrious history of rugby, where legends are immortalized for their feats on the field, there exists a cohort of players whose contributions often go unnoticed, overshadowed by the brilliance of their more celebrated counterparts. These unsung heroes, the backbone of their teams, embody the spirit of rugby with their selfless dedication, unyielding work ethic, and unparalleled skill. In this exploration, we shine a spotlight on the most underrated rugby players of all time, acknowledging their invaluable role in shaping the game.

1. Gareth Thomas (Wales): The Versatile Maestro:

A stalwart of Welsh rugby, Gareth Thomas stands as a beacon of versatility and adaptability. Capable of excelling at fullback, wing, or center, Thomas’s contributions to the Welsh national team often went overlooked. His powerful runs, defensive prowess, and leadership qualities were the underpinning of Wales’ successes, including their Six Nations Grand Slam in 2005.

2. Cornell du Preez (South Africa): The Unheralded Flanker:

In the fiercely competitive world of South African rugby, Cornell du Preez’s impact as a flanker for the Southern Kings and Edinburgh Rugby is often overlooked. Renowned for his relentless work rate, ball-carrying ability, and defensive tenacity, du Preez played a pivotal role in the trenches, providing the platform for his teams to flourish.

3. Conrad Smith (New Zealand): The Masterful Center:

Amidst the galaxy of stars in the New Zealand All Blacks, Conrad Smith’s brilliance at center often flew under the radar. Smith’s intelligence on the field, defensive astuteness, and ability to create space for his teammates made him an unsung hero in the All Blacks’ backline. His influence extended far beyond the try-scoring sheets, impacting the game in subtle yet profound ways.

4. Mike Brown (England): The Dependable Fullback:

Mike Brown, a consistent presence in the England national team, showcased the qualities of a dependable fullback that often went unheralded. Known for his aerial prowess, fearless tackling, and ability to inject pace into the attack, Brown’s contributions were foundational to England’s backline stability during his international career.

5. Martyn Williams (Wales): The Flanker Extraordinaire:

In the shadows of more celebrated Welsh players, Martyn Williams quietly forged a legacy as a flanker extraordinaire. His work at the breakdown, lineout expertise, and tireless defensive efforts were the unsung backbone of Welsh rugby. Williams’s impact extended beyond his playing days, influencing the next generation of Welsh flankers.

6. Ali Williams (New Zealand): The Lineout Virtuoso:

Ali Williams, a towering presence in the New Zealand second row, often played second fiddle to more flamboyant stars. However, his mastery of the lineout, exceptional athleticism, and leadership in the tight five were integral to the All Blacks’ set-piece dominance. Williams’s influence in the engine room was a cornerstone of New Zealand’s success.

7. Rod Kafer (Australia): The Midfield Maestro:

In a golden era of Australian rugby, Rod Kafer’s contributions as a midfield playmaker tend to be overshadowed. A gifted center with a deft passing touch and strategic vision, Kafer played a pivotal role in the Wallabies’ backline orchestrations. His ability to unlock defenses and create opportunities for his teammates often went unnoticed in the glare of the spotlight.

8. Jean de Villiers (South Africa): The Unassuming Leader:

As captain of the Springboks, Jean de Villiers led with a quiet strength that belied his impact. An intelligent center with a keen understanding of the game, de Villiers orchestrated the South African backline with precision. His leadership qualities were instrumental in navigating challenging periods for the Springboks, including their triumph in the 2009 British and Irish Lions series.

9. Jamie Cudmore (Canada): The Enforcer in the Pack:

Canadian rugby found its enforcer in Jamie Cudmore, a tireless lock who patrolled the forward trenches with unbridled intensity. Cudmore’s physicality, work rate, and uncompromising presence in the second row made him a linchpin for both Canada and his club sides, including ASM Clermont Auvergne in France.

10. Steve Thompson (England): The Silent Contributor:

Amidst the glitz of England’s 2003 Rugby World Cup-winning squad, Steve Thompson’s role as a hooker is often understated. His accuracy in the lineout, tenacity in the scrum, and tireless work in the loose made Thompson a silent contributor to England’s success. The unsung heroics of the front row are a testament to Thompson’s indomitable spirit.

11. Andrew Mehrtens (New Zealand): The Playmaking Virtuoso:

In the pantheon of New Zealand fly-halves, Andrew Mehrtens often doesn’t receive the acclaim he deserves. A playmaking virtuoso, Mehrtens orchestrated the All Blacks’ backline with flair and precision. His deft kicking, strategic vision, and ability to control the tempo of the game were foundational to New Zealand’s success during his international career.


The tapestry of rugby is woven with the threads of these underrated players, whose contributions, though often overlooked, are indispensable to the sport’s rich history. As we celebrate the legends and marvel at the star players, let us not forget the unsung heroes whose dedication, resilience, and skill have left an indelible mark on the game. In the quiet corners of rugby history, their stories echo the essence of the sport—a collective endeavor where every player, regardless of the spotlight, plays a vital role in the grand narrative of the game we hold dear.

Recent Posts